← Back to Blog

Chanukah Began With a Fight for the Brit Milah

By Rabbi Yossi Srugo | Miami Mohel | miamimohel.com

November 20, 2026

A brass menorah with blue and white candles glowing in a warm, softly lit Jewish home

Most of us grew up with the same Chanukah story: one tiny jar of oil, a flame that should have lasted a night, and a miracle that burned for eight.

It's a beautiful story. But after 19 years as a mohel, there's a part I always want to tell families, because almost nobody tells it: Chanukah began with a fight over the brit milah, the Jewish ritual of welcoming a baby boy on his eighth day.

Let me tell it the way I would in your living room.


A Decree Aimed at Jewish Babies

About 2,200 years ago, the land of Israel was ruled by a Greek-Syrian king named Antiochus. He wanted one culture across his whole kingdom: Greek gods, Greek customs, Greek everything.

So he outlawed the practices that made Jews Jewish. Keeping Shabbat. Studying Torah. And the brit milah.

Stop on that last one for a second. It wasn't a law about adults. It was a law about newborn sons. A family who gave their baby the covenant faced punishment, even death.


The Mark Some Tried to Hide

Not everyone resisted. Greek culture was modern, exciting, and powerful. The ancient sources even tell us that some men tried to hide the mark of the brit so they could fit in at the Greek gymnasium.

I find that very human. Who hasn't wanted to blend in?


The Family That Said No

Then a priest named Mattathias and his five sons, including Judah, known as the Maccabee, said no. They left their town and started a revolt. Along the way, they made sure Jewish baby boys were brought into the covenant, despite the decree.

And many mothers did the same, in secret, at terrible risk.

Against all odds, the small group won. They took back the Temple in Jerusalem and rededicated it. That word, rededication, is exactly what "Chanukah" means. And the oil? Our sages tell of one small jar that lasted eight days.


Why I Think About This at Every Bris

When I'm standing in a living room holding a newborn, surrounded by grandparents, with a room full of emotion, I sometimes think about those parents. No catered brunch. No photographer. Just a baby, a secret, and a decision.

Whatever your level of observance, a brit milah is a very old way of saying: this child belongs to a story bigger than all of us. Our ancestors protected that story with everything they had. When your family brings your son into the covenant, you carry it forward.

That's what Chanukah is really about. Not only light over darkness. Continuity.


A Chanukah Idea for New Parents

If you, or someone you love, is welcoming a baby boy, here are two ways to bring this story home.

The Bris Kit. A beautifully packed box with a post-care pouch, a kippa, an acrylic Shema plaque, a silver cup, Kedem grape juice, the "Now I'm Kosher" onesie, prayer cards, my children's book Shira n' Spice, and keepsakes to remember the day. $279, ships worldwide. Please order it at least one week before you need it.

Shira n' Spice, The Thank You Song. My children's book about gratitude and Modeh Ani. Amazon prints each copy to order, so it can take longer to arrive. Order early if you want it for Chanukah.

Wishing you and your family a bright and joyful Chanukah.

Related Reading